The title refers to the book written about Nortel called The Bubble and the Bear by Douglas Hunter, Doubleday, Toronto, 2002. Nortel was a high flying stock in the 1990s to 2001 when it crash and burned. In 2014 it is still being dismantled.
When Nortel stock was rapidly rising, similar to many other companies that have rapidly rising stocks, very few people care for the long term. There is a great many advantages to a rapidly rising stock price, the only disadvantage is at some point and nobody knows when, but at some point stocks will fall in price. Eventually the market determines what should be the price, but with a company such as Nortel the overwhelming market sentiment was on the rising price side. Nortel had many plus factors on its side – its heritage was AT&T and the Bell system. That was a terrific customer base – the phone companies had provide very stable, regulated profits every year. Along comes the internet, which Nortel has an distinct advantage in with optical technology and a long history of research and development. In addition as we switched from land lines to cell phone, Nortel had an advantage in their abilities to build the architecture of the system. An even bigger advantage was as a long established company – it had wonderful banking relations to do all the things which needed to be done. All the investment houses knocked on their doors for business and many were well rewarded. There was no reason not to doubt that when buying Nortel stock it was a good one to own.
The twin aspects of the internet and deregulation of AT&T changed the landscape. What in the past took decades for business to change, took an estimated 5 years before the mantra if you did not have internet and high speed, your economy is toast. There was a great deal of pressure and demand on companies to connect its customers to the internet – those that choose the right system won, those that choose the wrong one had to buy their way in to stay in the game. For a time, Nortel perhaps due to its roots in the telephone system was backing the wrong systems until it bought Bay Networks, then it had the reach of the correct system used in the internet. Nortel stock continue to rise, there was no reason to doubt it should not rise.
As the internet changed business, it changed Nortel’s customers who went from the very solid Bell systems to those that wanted to compete against the bell systems such as MCI and WorldCom. The Bell systems had monopolized the phone systems and MCI, Sprint and WorldCom all wanted to lower the costs of long distance phone calls. To their credit, long distance rates fell rapidly, which was good. What was bad was so did the profit margins. With the rise of the internet, data transmission was more important than voice. In many cities if you build new roads, soon they will be filled with cars. In the middle of the US, if you build a new road, there will be no extra cars than which already exists. In order to have a infrastructure for the internet, new roads across the US were built. It was later that people asked about usage capacity.
When usage capacity began to be asked, and the answer was below 10%, the next question to be raised was how does the company make money? It would take 6 months before anyone would listen to those could not figure out how the company was making money. As the company stock was doing very well and continually rising, it was assumed the users were paying the bills. It turned out, that would happen, it was just not happening right away.
Linking to dividend paying stocks, all industries changed and have gone through great changes, those that make a profit and pay dividends are to be congratulate as an investor, every once in a while, you should ask how does the company that you own make money? What sort of margins does it make and how stable on the bulk of profitable sales and services is it? Sometimes you should be the devil’s advocate and pay attention to those who have a completely different opinion of the company. When you are reasonable certain on the answers, then you can let the company do its thing and continue to pay you dividends.
There are more questions than answers, till the next time – to raising questions